(c) all rights reserved · dverse · poetry

dVerse — soliloquy — view from the trail

Image result for hound on the winter trail painting

Situation:
In a small group discussion last night, we compared Judas to The Prodigal Son as far as regret, attitude, behavior, motivation; during the discussion a disagreement arose. One camp felt that, even though Jesus knew he was going to be betrayed and said as much to Judas, “Do what you have to do.,” Judas still had the choice to walk away from betraying Jesus for the silver. The other camp felt that the scenario that led to the betrayal and what came after it was pre-ordained, that Judas had his part to play in it; his choice had been removed.

The conversation then moved to the severity of the offenses between what Judas did and what The Prodigal Son did. The consensus was that Judas’ offense was of a much higher level of severity than the son’s. This moved the conversation on to whether or not there are those who choose to consort with evil forces and are beyond redeeming at some point. The belief of most was that anyone can be redeemed, no matter what, but it has to be a conscious turning away from evil on their part and a change of heart that begs for redemption.

My thoughts travel like a hound on the hunt, sniffing for clues to prey.
My pray like prey, seeking out those perfect answers and manifestations.
Humans divine sin in their own way, imperfect transmitters of a perfect God

Or are we? Are we imperfect transmitters?

Perfect snowflakes wander to earth. Are drops of rain any less perfect?
Each arrangement of molecules, properties meant to be by the laws of physics
Does God play between the molecules?

I’m running in circles. My thoughts tire. The trail is gone.
I curl by the fire and watch the snowflakes wander to earth.
There is no self-blame.

Frank Hubeny is today’s host of dVerse.  Frank says:
Write a poem using soliloquy in some way. It may even be a poem you now see could be interpreted as a soliloquy.  For this prompt one may want to add a dramatic context perhaps as a brief paragraph explaining the scene and then let the poem express one character’s perspective on that context…

image link here

27 thoughts on “dVerse — soliloquy — view from the trail

  1. I like the question whether we are “imperfect transmitters” or not of a prefect God. I hadn’t thought of it like that before. I guess that makes this a very good soliloquy. It left me, a reader, with further questioning to continue the soliloquy on my own. I generally do think we have at least enough free will to ask for forgiveness however else we might be tossed about. That may have been Judas’s main mistake – to not seek forgiveness afterwards. But I don’t know.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. The Book of Judas in the Gnostic texts shed more light on the matter; he played his part. Your preface loomed large over your clever couplets. Your questioning is well balanced by your ending.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. The biblical discussion….then into the poetic write, the questions and the spinning from all the questions and the play on words prey/pray. Almost a stream of consciousness toward the end. Questions can turn circles within our minds. Sometimes the answers do elude us.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I enjoyed the meandering of your poem, Jade, and the idea of humans as imperfect transmitters. I especially liked these lines:
    ‘Perfect snowflakes wander to earth. Are drops of rain any less perfect?
    Each arrangement of molecules, properties meant to be by the laws of physics
    Does God play between the molecules?’
    An interesting question.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Hooray no Hamlet’s shadow in this soliloquy – and a genuine philosophically valid question answered to perfection! We cannot think our way through mystery. Your final line is pure balm.

    Re your intro – I am very intrigued that no one mentioned the ideas that the betrayal was an agreement forged between Judas and Jesus and that Judas’ role led to such inner anguish that he committed suicide, thus becoming the unwarranted collateral damage of a too demanding God. Not my original idea, but makes sense historically as the hatching of a revolutionary plot by a Hebrew freedom fighter.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Christine, great comments! Thank you for another perspective on the situation. I’ll bring it to the group next week so they have another flower for the vase to consider.

      Like

  6. The concept of comparison .. snowflake to rain … captured my fancy. There are those who present attractively as a snowflake, but inside they are simply rain. What you see is not necessarily what you get, so to speak. But ……. I soliloquize …………………

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Fascinating and insightful poem. I have pondered this – years ago – and so far (I may change my mind someday) I imagine God (the holy trinity which includes Jesus) as being outside of time and we humans are inside of “time”. Like a book that has a beginning, middle, and end and at the same time each person in it has free will. God is outside the book and can skip ahead or back to any page while we forge ahead, page by page (pages that have yet to be written as we are in time. ) So… Judas had free choice, but Jesus knew the story (because he is outside of time) and yes, I think Judas did regret it as he hung himself… I like to think just before he died his heart was sorrowful and pleaded forgiveness.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.